“You could have chosen differently.”
It is an easy thing to say after something has happened. We say it to other people. Sometimes we carry it around and say it to ourselves. Looking back, the other road can seem so obvious that we forget how much of the map became visible afterward.
I was watching a discussion about free will in a StarTalk reel on Facebook, and I found myself questioning something more basic: what do we actually mean when we say someone could have chosen differently?
I do not believe that having a choice automatically means having free will. There are options in front of us, certainly. But there is also the person looking at those options. How much did that person choose about becoming who they are?
The discussion brought up brain activity appearing before someone becomes aware of intending to act. In Benjamin Libet’s experiments, a signal associated with preparation for movement began roughly 350 milliseconds before participants reported their conscious intention, on average.[1]
My first reaction was fairly blunt: if the brain has already made the decision before I know about it, where exactly is the free will?
There is a qualification I have to keep. The experiment measured early brain activity and reported awareness. It did not establish that every decision is complete and irreversible before consciousness arrives. Later research questioned whether that early signal necessarily marks a settled decision at all.[2] That matters, even when it complicates the conclusion I was ready to draw.
But then I ran into another problem.
You can repeat the procedure. You cannot give the participant back the moment before they experienced it.
Run the experiment again and you have someone who has already done it. They remember. They anticipate. They may be trying to give the same answer, or a different one, or wondering what the researcher expects. Even without any deliberate strategy, the first experience is now part of their history.
You have changed the circumstances by creating another experience.
So when someone says I could have chosen differently under exactly the same conditions, I want to know how we would establish that. A hypothetical rewind can restore everything in an argument. We cannot perform that rewind on a person.
I also have to accept where that objection stops. It does not prove that the choice was inevitable. Only one outcome happened. Whether another outcome was genuinely possible remains the disputed part.
That leaves me with a belief I can argue for, rather than a scientific verdict I can announce.
I doubt free will in the sense of being the ultimate author of my choices. I did not choose my starting temperament or the world I arrived in. I did not choose the earliest experiences through which I learned what was safe, what was possible, or what to expect from other people.
I can question those things now. I can try to change. But the desire to change comes from somewhere too: something learned, something endured, a conversation, a consequence, another person making a possibility visible.
Philosopher Galen Strawson develops a similar challenge to ultimate responsibility: even our attempts to change ourselves begin with the person we already are.[3] I find that difficult to dismiss.
It also brings this out of the laboratory and into the uncomfortable business of living with ourselves.
When we look back at a decision we regret, we bring knowledge that was not available then. We may bring more stability, more support, or simply the consequences of the decision itself. Imagining how we would act now is useful. It is not a clean demonstration of what was available to us then.
That does not erase harm or remove the need to answer for what we do. Someone hurt by a decision still has to live with it. Boundaries still matter. So does repair where repair is possible.
But I am less comfortable with the extra judgment that someone should simply have been a different person in that moment. I am less comfortable directing it at myself, too.
I do not think this makes rebuilding pointless. Thinking, learning and support can influence what happens next. Even if those processes have causes, they can have effects. The fact that I did not create my starting conditions does not make the conditions around me now irrelevant.
I started with a Facebook reel and an argument about a fraction of a second. I have ended up thinking about the much longer history behind a choice, and how little of that history we see when we judge it.
I still doubt free will. I cannot honestly say the experiments have settled it.
But the next time I hear “you could have chosen differently,” I want to leave room for a question that sentence usually skips: what would have needed to be different for that other choice to become possible?
