We Have Choices. How Free Are They?

Painting of plants, mushrooms, stars, galaxies, and orbiting planets

“You could have chosen differently.”

It is an easy thing to say after something has happened. We say it to other people. Sometimes we carry it around and say it to ourselves. Looking back, the other road can seem so obvious that we forget how much of the map became visible afterward.

I was watching a discussion about free will in a StarTalk reel on Facebook, and I found myself questioning something more basic: what do we actually mean when we say someone could have chosen differently?

I do not believe that having a choice automatically means having free will. There are options in front of us, certainly. But there is also the person looking at those options. How much did that person choose about becoming who they are?

The discussion brought up brain activity appearing before someone becomes aware of intending to act. In Benjamin Libet’s experiments, a signal associated with preparation for movement began roughly 350 milliseconds before participants reported their conscious intention, on average.[1]

My first reaction was fairly blunt: if the brain has already made the decision before I know about it, where exactly is the free will?

There is a qualification I have to keep. The experiment measured early brain activity and reported awareness. It did not establish that every decision is complete and irreversible before consciousness arrives. Later research questioned whether that early signal necessarily marks a settled decision at all.[2] That matters, even when it complicates the conclusion I was ready to draw.

But then I ran into another problem.

You can repeat the procedure. You cannot give the participant back the moment before they experienced it.

Run the experiment again and you have someone who has already done it. They remember. They anticipate. They may be trying to give the same answer, or a different one, or wondering what the researcher expects. Even without any deliberate strategy, the first experience is now part of their history.

You have changed the circumstances by creating another experience.

So when someone says I could have chosen differently under exactly the same conditions, I want to know how we would establish that. A hypothetical rewind can restore everything in an argument. We cannot perform that rewind on a person.

I also have to accept where that objection stops. It does not prove that the choice was inevitable. Only one outcome happened. Whether another outcome was genuinely possible remains the disputed part.

That leaves me with a belief I can argue for, rather than a scientific verdict I can announce.

I doubt free will in the sense of being the ultimate author of my choices. I did not choose my starting temperament or the world I arrived in. I did not choose the earliest experiences through which I learned what was safe, what was possible, or what to expect from other people.

I can question those things now. I can try to change. But the desire to change comes from somewhere too: something learned, something endured, a conversation, a consequence, another person making a possibility visible.

Philosopher Galen Strawson develops a similar challenge to ultimate responsibility: even our attempts to change ourselves begin with the person we already are.[3] I find that difficult to dismiss.

It also brings this out of the laboratory and into the uncomfortable business of living with ourselves.

When we look back at a decision we regret, we bring knowledge that was not available then. We may bring more stability, more support, or simply the consequences of the decision itself. Imagining how we would act now is useful. It is not a clean demonstration of what was available to us then.

That does not erase harm or remove the need to answer for what we do. Someone hurt by a decision still has to live with it. Boundaries still matter. So does repair where repair is possible.

But I am less comfortable with the extra judgment that someone should simply have been a different person in that moment. I am less comfortable directing it at myself, too.

I do not think this makes rebuilding pointless. Thinking, learning and support can influence what happens next. Even if those processes have causes, they can have effects. The fact that I did not create my starting conditions does not make the conditions around me now irrelevant.

I started with a Facebook reel and an argument about a fraction of a second. I have ended up thinking about the much longer history behind a choice, and how little of that history we see when we judge it.

I still doubt free will. I cannot honestly say the experiments have settled it.

But the next time I hear “you could have chosen differently,” I want to leave room for a question that sentence usually skips: what would have needed to be different for that other choice to become possible?

The Man Selling America’s Inheritance

Man selling America’s inheritance

Trump says Canada is destroying itself. What he cannot see is that he is spending economic advantages, alliances and international trust that took the United States generations to build.

By Lugh Sulian

Hey there, my dear Unplugged Pagans.

Donald Trump has once again declared that Canada is “systematically destroying itself.”

Well, pull up a chair and pour something warm, because Lugh has found himself another rabbit hole—and this particular rabbit appears to be wearing a red tie, carrying a tariff schedule and trying to sell us the fence it just tore out of the ground.

Canada is destroying itself?

Really?

Canada did not begin this confrontation. Canada did not suddenly impose punitive tariffs upon its closest trading partner. Canada did not threaten American sovereignty, suggest annexing the United States or repeatedly refer to its elected leader as a provincial governor.

Trump did those things to Canada.

Now that Canada is looking for other customers, other suppliers and more reliable partners, Trump calls it self-destruction.

That is not economic analysis.

It is the language of control: “You forced me to hurt you—and if you become less dependent upon me, you are hurting yourself.”

Let Us Begin With an Uncomfortable Truth

Trump can damage Canada.

He already has.

Canada’s merchandise exports to the United States fell sharply following the imposition of American tariffs. Trade uncertainty has discouraged Canadian investment and hiring. Industries built around predictable access to the American market have been forced to reconsider plans that once appeared perfectly sensible.

Canada remains deeply dependent upon the United States, particularly in energy, agriculture, manufacturing and transportation. Geography matters. Infrastructure matters. More than a century of economic integration cannot be untangled over a long weekend with a pot of coffee and a fresh map.

Canadian diversification will be difficult, expensive and slow.

But that is precisely why it has become necessary.

Dependence upon the United States made economic sense when the United States behaved like a dependable partner. It makes considerably less sense when access to its market can be threatened according to one president’s political grievance, negotiating tactic or morning social-media mood.

Canada is not abandoning a reliable relationship.

Canada is adapting to the fact that the relationship is no longer reliable.

The “Drop-Off Port” That Does Not Exist

Trump claims that Canada’s agreement with China will turn this country into a “drop-off port” through which Chinese products can slip into the United States.

It sounds alarming. It also falls apart when examined.

The agreement initially allows up to 49,000 Chinese electric vehicles into Canada at a reduced tariff. That amounts to less than three per cent of Canada’s overall new-vehicle market.

Those cars do not magically become Canadian products when they cross the Pacific.

CUSMA rules of origin still determine whether a vehicle qualifies for preferential entry into the United States. A Chinese-built car cannot be unloaded in Vancouver, decorated with a maple leaf and sent tariff-free across the border while a customs officer politely looks the other way.

Canada also requires shipment-specific permits for the covered Chinese vehicles.

There are legitimate concerns surrounding the agreement. Chinese industrial subsidies, connected-vehicle security, domestic auto employment and the future size of the electric-vehicle quota deserve serious examination. Canada should not trade one dangerous dependency for another.

But the arrangement also restored access to an important Chinese market for Canadian farmers. China agreed to reduce its combined tariff on Canadian canola seed from approximately 84 per cent to about 15 per cent, affecting a Canadian export market worth roughly $4 billion annually.

That is not Canada surrendering itself to China.

It is Canada attempting to recover a market after the United States demonstrated that excessive dependence upon any single country is dangerous.

Tariffs Are Not Bills Mailed to Foreign Countries

Trump speaks about tariffs as though American customs agents march north, knock on Parliament’s door and present Canada with an invoice.

That is not how tariffs work.

A tariff is paid by the importer bringing a product into the United States. That importer may absorb part of the cost, pass it along to another American business or charge American consumers more.

Federal Reserve researchers estimated that tariffs imposed through November 2025 had raised American core-goods prices by 3.1 per cent by February 2026. They attributed the excess inflation in that category to the tariffs and estimated that tariffs added approximately 0.8 per cent to core consumer prices overall.

That is not foreign countries paying America.

That is Americans paying more inside America.

Tariffs can sometimes protect a strategic domestic industry. They can create negotiating leverage. They can be useful when narrowly applied and attached to a coherent industrial policy.

But tariffs are not magic.

They cannot instantly create aluminum smelters, mines, refineries, skilled workers, electrical capacity, transportation infrastructure or decades of accumulated industrial knowledge.

When applied indiscriminately, they become a tax on the very manufacturers they are supposed to protect.

The Aluminum Lesson

The United States placed heavy tariffs on Canadian aluminum while simultaneously acknowledging that American industry desperately needs aluminum.

There is a reason the United States buys so much of it from Canada.

Producing primary aluminum requires enormous amounts of reliable electricity. Canada—particularly Quebec—possesses abundant hydroelectric generating capacity and an established smelting industry. America cannot replace that production overnight merely because a president demands it.

After the tariffs were imposed, the price paid by American aluminum buyers climbed dramatically. Those costs do not stop at the border. They move into automobiles, aircraft, appliances, construction materials, machinery and beverage cans.

Trump may punish a Canadian smelter.

He also raises costs for the American factory that needs what the smelter produces.

That is the recurring flaw in Trump’s economic thinking: he treats every imported item as evidence of American defeat rather than asking why American businesses import it and what happens when its price suddenly rises.

The Potash Parable

Then we come to potash.

The United States imports most of the potash it uses, and Canada supplies the overwhelming majority of those imports. Saskatchewan’s deposits are among the largest and most dependable sources in the world.

Potash is not some decorative luxury. It is fertilizer. American farmers use it to maintain soil productivity and crop yields.

Trump now proposes buying cheaper potash from Belarus.

Let us pause beside that stump for a moment.

In order to punish Canada—one of America’s oldest allies and the established source of most American potash imports—Trump is looking toward Alexander Lukashenko’s authoritarian Belarus.

Perhaps the quoted price is lower. But a businessman should understand that the number written on a sales proposal is not the entire cost.

Transportation matters. Ports matter. Sanctions matter. Political stability matters. Delivery schedules matter. Supply security matters.

A cheap product that cannot reliably reach the farm is not cheap.

There is also a broader absurdity here. Trump condemns Canada for conducting limited trade with China while his own government seeks a strategic agricultural commodity from Belarus.

Apparently, trading with an authoritarian government is national destruction when Canada does it and brilliant deal-making when Trump does it.

That rabbit is beginning to smell rather peculiar.

North America Is Not Three Separate Machines

The Canadian and American economies were not constructed as two tidy boxes placed beside one another.

They function more like an old forest: roots crossing beneath the border, resources moving toward factories, components travelling back and forth, and communities on both sides depending upon relationships that are not always visible from the surface.

Canada sends roughly four million barrels of crude oil south each day. Canadian energy helps power American transportation and industry. Canada supplies aluminum, potash, electricity, critical minerals and automotive components.

In the automotive sector, a component may cross the border several times before the completed vehicle reaches a dealership.

Every tariff placed along that journey adds another cost.

That does not make American manufacturing more efficient. It makes the shared North American manufacturing system more expensive.

Trump sees a border and imagines a wall between two economies.

The supply chain sees a seam.

America’s Greatest Advantage Was Trust

The greatest damage Trump is causing may not appear immediately in employment reports, stock-market indexes or quarterly trade figures.

For generations, American power rested upon more than the size of its economy and military.

It rested upon trust.

Countries constructed their industries, trade routes, security policies and financial systems around the United States because America was generally considered stable. Agreements survived changes of government. Allies could disagree with Washington without expecting threats to their national existence. American leadership was powerful because participation in the American-led system usually offered mutual benefit.

That was an extraordinary economic advantage.

Trump is spending it.

He treats trust as weakness, cooperation as charity and interdependence as evidence that someone must be cheating America. He sees every relationship as a one-time transaction in which one side wins only if the other side loses.

But trust, like fertile soil, takes years to build and can be stripped away remarkably quickly.

When market access becomes a weapon, other countries begin searching for protection from that weapon.

They find new customers.

They construct new ports.

They negotiate new agreements.

They develop new supply chains.

They strengthen relationships with Europe, Asia and other middle powers.

And once those alternatives exist, they do not automatically disappear when another president enters the White House.

The Cost of Making Allies Afraid

Trump appears to believe that making other countries fear America proves that America is strong.

Fear can produce concessions.

But it also produces contingency plans.

Canada is now pursuing closer economic relationships with Europe and Asia. Canadian exports to countries other than the United States have grown while exports to America have declined. Canadian travellers redirected billions of dollars in spending away from the United States and toward Canada, Europe, Asia and other destinations.

Other American allies are doing their own calculations.

They are asking whether Washington can still be trusted. They are deciding whether defence, technology, energy and trade systems built around the United States leave them too vulnerable to American political instability.

This is how influence is lost—not necessarily in one dramatic collapse, but through thousands of quiet decisions made in boardrooms, ministries, factories and foreign capitals.

One supplier is replaced.

One holiday is taken elsewhere.

One military purchase goes to another country.

One new factory is constructed outside the American system.

One government decides that Washington must be managed rather than trusted.

No single decision ends American power.

Together, they erode it.

The Axe Is Striking the Roots

There is an old mistake made by those who inherit something powerful.

They assume they created it.

Trump inherited the world’s largest economy, the dominant international currency, an immense consumer market, unmatched military alliances and a network of trading relationships built over generations.

He mistakes possession of that inheritance for proof of his own economic genius.

He believes the tree is so large that he can continue swinging an axe into its roots without consequence.

And perhaps for a while he can.

The United States remains enormously powerful. Canada cannot painlessly abandon its largest market. Most countries will continue doing business with America because its economy is simply too large to ignore.

But being too large to ignore is not the same as being trusted.

It is not the same as being admired.

It is not the same as being followed.

Trump can force allies to make concessions today while teaching them never to become so vulnerable to the United States again.

That may be the most expensive bargain America has ever made.

So, Who Is Destroying Whom?

Canada is not destroying itself by seeking alternatives to an unreliable partner.

Canada is responding—painfully, imperfectly and belatedly—to a vulnerability that Trump exposed.

We should not romanticize the process. Canada will lose jobs, investment and opportunities along the way. We will make mistakes. We must be careful not to replace dependence upon Washington with dependence upon Beijing.

But resilience requires more than hoping the next American administration will put everything back the way it was.

The old relationship may not be recoverable because trust, once broken, does not return simply because the person who broke it has left the room.

Trump is not single-handedly destroying the United States.

That claim would be too broad, too easy and too much like Trump’s own habit of turning every disagreement into an apocalypse.

What he is doing is more precise—and perhaps more consequential.

He is eroding America’s economic advantages, weakening its alliances and teaching the world how dangerous dependence upon the United States can be.

Canada may suffer while learning to live with less America.

But America may one day discover that making its allies fear dependence upon it was a remarkably effective way to make itself less necessary.

The tree will not fall today.

But the axe is striking the roots.

Godspeed, my dear Unplugged Pagans.

Lugh Sulian


Sources and Further Reading

No One Has to Order Us into the Cities

It began with a question that sounded simple enough: is the government slowly trying to move people out of rural communities and into cities, where we will become more dependent upon commercial systems for the necessities of life?

It is the sort of question that can be answered too quickly from either direction. One person hears it and immediately declares a conspiracy. Another hears it and dismisses the whole concern as paranoia. Neither answer requires much investigation, and neither one does justice to what rural people can see happening around them.

So I followed the rabbit.

What I found was not evidence of one secret Canadian plan whose stated purpose is to empty the countryside and manufacture obedient consumers. What I found was something less dramatic, more ordinary and, in some ways, more difficult to confront. Governments, banks, utilities, retailers and service providers do not need to sit around the same table. They only need to follow the same arithmetic: concentrate services where there are more people, withdraw them where there are fewer, and transfer the cost of distance to whoever remains.

The result can resemble a relocation policy even when nobody publishes one.

The long road toward the centre

Canada has been urbanizing for generations. Statistics Canada reports that in 1851, roughly 84 percent of the population lived in rural areas. By 2011, fewer than one Canadian in five did. That enormous change was connected to industrialization, mechanized agriculture, wage employment, education and the concentration of services. It cannot reasonably be blamed on a single modern government or policy.

We should not pretend, however, that Canadian governments have never deliberately encouraged people to leave small communities. Newfoundland and Labrador’s resettlement programs provide a documented example. Between 1965 and 1970 alone, 16,114 people from 119 communities were resettled. The reasoning was recognizable: concentrating the population would make public services and economic development easier and less expensive to provide.

Those memories did not disappear when the formal programs ended. A later Newfoundland and Labrador public consultation recorded residents describing the gradual removal of teachers, medical professionals, grants and other services as “resettlement by stealth”. That phrase matters. It describes a process in which nobody is physically ordered from a home, but the supports required to remain there are removed one by one.

The evidence that complicates the claim

If there were one unified contemporary plan to depopulate rural Canada, we would have to explain the policies moving in the opposite direction. The federal government maintains a Rural Economic Development Strategy, funds rural infrastructure and operates a Rural Community Immigration Pilot intended to attract workers and permanent residents to rural and remote communities.

The population numbers are not a simple story of everyone being funnelled toward Toronto, Ottawa or Vancouver either. Statistics Canada’s recent estimates show that from 2021 to 2025, rural and small-town populations increased in ten of the thirteen provinces and territories. Between July 2024 and July 2025, Ontario recorded a net movement of more than 15,000 people from functional urban areas into rural areas and small towns. The countryside is not emptying in one uniform national march. The movement runs in both directions.

Government housing policy also needs to be read accurately. Programs such as the Housing Accelerator Fund openly encourage denser housing, mixed-use neighbourhoods and development near transit. Those are real urban-concentration policies, but their stated objectives are to increase housing supply, use infrastructure efficiently and reduce transportation pressures—not to order existing rural residents into cities. Some of the same funding also reaches smaller communities.

This counter-evidence is important because a rabbit trail should lead where the ground goes, not where we had already decided it must end. There is no persuasive evidence here of one coordinated master plan. But that does not make the broader pattern imaginary.

The institutions are leaving before the people do

A community does not cease to be viable only when its last resident leaves. It begins to weaken when the ordinary institutions that make daily life possible decide that the community is no longer worth serving.

Consider banking. According to the Canadian Bankers Association, Canada had 6,205 bank branches in 2012 and 5,656 in 2022, a decline of nine percent. Measured per 100,000 adults, the reduction was about fifteen percent between 2012 and 2021. Urban branches close too, but an urban customer may have several alternatives within a short distance. When a rural community loses its only branch, banking itself leaves town.

Federal rules recognize that difference. Where a rural branch has no other deposit-taking branch within ten kilometres, the bank must provide six months’ notice, notify the local government and publish notice locally. Those rules may give residents time to prepare, but they generally manage the closure rather than prevent it.

The bank saves the expense of a building and its employees. The resident acquires the expense of reliable internet, a suitable device, digital competence and transportation to the next town whenever an in-person service is unavoidable. A private cost has not vanished. It has merely been moved from the institution to the customer.

Health care follows a similar geography. A Statistics Canada proximity study found that approximately 97 percent of people in large metropolitan areas lived within a three-kilometre drive of a health-care facility. In rural areas, only about half did. That measurement does not tell us whether a doctor is available or how long the wait will be, but it captures the first barrier: the service is physically farther away.

Now add schools, government counters, repair shops, grocery stores and public transportation. Each closure is announced as a separate decision. Each one may be justified by its own budget. Yet rural residents do not experience them separately. They experience the accumulated distance.

The rural access penalty

Distance has a price, and rural people often pay it more than once.

Natural Resources Canada identifies transportation costs, local competition, consumer choice and sales volume among the reasons gasoline prices differ between communities. Remote stations generally pay more to bring fuel from the refinery or terminal. Smaller markets may have fewer stations competing for customers and lower sales volumes over which to spread fixed costs.

The rural resident can therefore face a higher price per litre while also needing more litres. The bank is farther away. The hospital is farther away. The job, school and large grocery store may all be farther away. In a city, transit, walking or a short drive may provide alternatives. Across much of rural Canada, the vehicle is not a luxury. It is the admission price for participating in ordinary life.

Electricity reveals the same density calculation. In Ontario, the commodity price of electricity may be standardized under a chosen price plan, but delivery costs depend upon the infrastructure required to reach the customer. Hydro One openly classifies customers by urban, medium and low density, and Ontario maintains Distribution Rate Protection and Rural or Remote Electricity Rate Protection because rural delivery is intrinsically more expensive.

The difference is especially clear for small businesses. In Hydro One’s 2026 schedule, a general-service customer using less than 50 kilowatts faced a distribution charge of 3.26 cents per kilowatt-hour in an urban area and 7.33 cents in a non-urban area. The non-urban monthly service charge was also higher. The published rates show that a rural business can pay more than twice the urban distribution charge before it sells a single product to a neighbour.

That cost eventually appears somewhere. It appears in the price on the shelf, in the wage that cannot be offered, in the repair that is postponed or in the decision that the business can no longer remain open. The closure then reduces local competition and forces residents to travel farther, returning us to the gasoline pump once again.

Efficiency is not the same as independence

The strongest part of this rabbit trail may not be about what rural residents are charged. It may be about what urban residents lose the practical ability to do for themselves.

Cities are efficient at the scale of systems. One water main can serve hundreds of homes. One transit route can move thousands of people. A hospital can draw specialists and equipment into one place. That efficiency is real, and it can improve lives. But efficiency for the system is not the same thing as autonomy for the household.

A rural property may provide enough land for a serious garden, an orchard, chickens, a greenhouse, food storage, rain collection, a workshop or a woodlot. None of those things guarantees self-sufficiency. Land requires knowledge, health, time, tools and money, and rural living should never be romanticized as effortless independence. What the land preserves is the possibility of producing at least part of what the household needs.

Urban residents can and do grow food on balconies, indoors and in community gardens. Their ingenuity deserves respect. The limits are nevertheless visible in the data. Statistics Canada found that in 2023, 66 percent of owner households grew fruit, herbs, vegetables or flowers for personal use, compared with 38 percent of renter households. Most growers used a yard; only a small minority used a community garden. Tenure and housing form shape the opportunity to grow.

A few pots of herbs can restore relationship and teach a great deal, but they ordinarily cannot supply a household with potatoes, squash, beans, fruit and preserved food through an Ontario winter. When land access disappears, food becomes something almost entirely purchased rather than partly produced.

Heating follows the same distinction. A rural homeowner may be able to install a wood stove, maintain a woodlot, store fuel or keep more than one source of heat available. An apartment resident normally uses whatever system the landlord, utility or condominium corporation has selected. That does not automatically make urban heating dirtier. Ontario’s electrical grid draws heavily upon nuclear and hydroelectric generation, alongside natural gas, wind, solar and bioenergy. Electric heat can therefore be relatively low-carbon even though not every generation source is renewable. The deeper issue is that the resident usually cannot choose, repair or replace the system independently.

Nor does rural freedom of choice guarantee low energy costs. Ontario’s own Electrification and Energy Transition Panel observed that rural households have much higher overall home-energy costs than urban households, largely because many do not have access to pipeline natural gas and instead rely upon electricity, propane, oil or wood. The ability to choose among imperfect alternatives is still not the same thing as having an affordable alternative.

In the city, food, heat, water, shelter and waste removal arrive through managed networks. Those networks can be remarkably reliable—until access depends upon employment, rent, a functioning account and the ability to keep paying. The household becomes efficient because it has outsourced much of its survival.

Naming the pattern without inventing the conspiracy

Two thinkers helped me understand what this rabbit had uncovered.

In Seeing Like a State, political scientist James C. Scott examined how large administrative systems simplify complicated local realities into forms that can be measured and managed from the centre. Scott was not writing specifically about present-day rural Ontario, and it would be unfair to claim that he proved this argument for us. His work nevertheless gives us a useful lens: dense, standardized populations are easier for institutions to see, serve and administer than scattered households with different local practices.

Ivan Illich offered another useful idea in Tools for Conviviality: the “radical monopoly.” This is larger than one company controlling a market. It occurs when one kind of system becomes so dominant that meaningful alternatives become difficult or impossible. A person may theoretically remain free to walk, grow food, heat with local fuel or bank in person, while the world around them is reorganized in ways that make those choices increasingly impractical.

That, I believe, is closer to what we are seeing.

There does not need to be a secret meeting between Ottawa, the banks, Hydro One, grocery chains and municipal planners. Each institution can follow its own incentives. Governments often seek administrative efficiency. Banks seek lower operating costs. Retailers seek volume. Utilities price the cost of distance. Developers seek profitable density. Environmental policy favours shorter trips and shared infrastructure. None of those motives, examined alone, proves an intention to manufacture dependence.

Put them together, however, and they produce a recognizable direction of travel. Rural residents pay more to reach fewer services. Urban residents receive closer services but lose land, choice and the capacity to provide more of life’s necessities directly. One side is penalized for distance; the other is rewarded for surrendering autonomy to centralized networks.

A Pagan question of relationship and place

This is where the subject belongs on Unplugged Pagan.

Paganism is not made authentic by a postal code. A person living in a high-rise can maintain profound relationships with the seasons, the ancestors, the local watershed and the other-than-human world. A person surrounded by a hundred rural acres can remain completely disconnected from the land beneath their feet. City Paganism is no contradiction, and rural residence is no spiritual credential.

But land access matters. The ability to plant, harvest, compost, preserve, mend, build and gather fuel changes our relationship with necessity. Food is no longer only a product appearing beneath fluorescent lights. Heat is no longer merely a number on a bill. Water does not begin at the tap, and waste does not cease to exist when the truck carries it away.

Those acts teach reciprocity because the consequences remain near us. The soil answers what we put into it. The woodpile remembers whether we prepared in summer. The pantry records both abundance and neglect. Self-sufficiency is never complete—we have always depended upon neighbours, craftspeople, trade and community—but local competence gives us something different from commercial isolation. It allows dependence to become visible, chosen and reciprocal rather than distant, mandatory and anonymous.

That is not nostalgia for some imaginary past in which everyone lived alone in a cabin. It is an argument for preserving human-scale choices: the right to grow meaningful amounts of food, to use safe local heating alternatives, to maintain local businesses, to reach essential services without surrendering an entire day, and to remain in a rural community without being charged repeatedly for the privilege.

The difference between intended and accepted

I cannot honestly conclude that the Canadian government is operating one concealed program to force rural people into cities for the purpose of increasing commercial dependence. The evidence does not establish that claim, and some evidence directly complicates it.

I can conclude that governments and corporations repeatedly make decisions that privilege density, centralization and institutional scale. I can conclude that these decisions progressively remove services and productive choices from rural communities. I can conclude that the resulting costs are transferred to rural residents, while urban residents are made increasingly dependent upon landlords, utilities, retailers and managed systems for basic necessities.

Most importantly, I can conclude that these outcomes are foreseeable.

Once an outcome is understood and the same decisions continue, the question changes. We are no longer arguing only about whether dependence was the original intention. We must also ask why it remains an acceptable consequence.

A serious rural policy would measure more than population growth and infrastructure cost. It would measure how much practical choice remains. Can residents still obtain cash and speak to a banker? Can an older person reach health care? Can a household grow food or maintain a safe backup source of heat? Can a small business survive its delivery charges? Can young people build a life locally rather than being told that opportunity lives somewhere else?

The rabbit did not lead me to a hidden room where powerful people were drawing arrows from every farmhouse toward the city. It led somewhere far more familiar: to the locked door of a former bank, the long drive to a medical appointment, the higher number at the gasoline pump, the delivery line on a hydro bill and the small balcony expected to take the place of a garden.

No one has to order us into the cities if remaining outside them is made steadily more expensive, more inconvenient and less possible.

There it goes again.

Godspeed.


Sources and further reading

The Work Must Outlive Its Founder

Hands pass firekeeping tools beside a communal woodland fire

A rabbit has emerged from the undergrowth between our look at The Heathen Underground and our return to Declaration 127. It is not another rabbit about folkism, Facebook or declarations. It is carrying a ring of old keys in its mouth and appears to be wondering who will open the doors when the person who built the house is no longer standing there.

The Heathen Underground began under Heather O’Brien. In 2017, responsibility for it passed to Nicole Butler, who publicly thanked Heather for trusting her with what she described as the torch. Declaration 127 followed a different path. It was created by a team, maintained by a committee and then left without an active home after that committee burned out and its website disappeared. In 2024, Rob Schreiwer transferred stewardship of Declaration 127 and its associated assets to The Troth.

These are separate projects with separate histories. Their leadership changes do not demonstrate shared ownership, coordination or some hidden organizational structure. What they share is a much more ordinary—and much more important—problem faced by nearly every volunteer Pagan undertaking.

How does the work continue after the people who began it can no longer carry it?

The Founder and the Work

Founders matter. Someone has to be the first person to strike the match, register the domain, create the group, write the declaration, rent the field, call the meeting or place the first stone. Without that first stubborn person, many of the things we later call community would never exist.

The difficulty begins when the founder and the work become indistinguishable. The project becomes known as one person’s group, one person’s festival, one person’s ritual or one person’s vision. Every decision returns to the same hands. Knowledge stays in one head. Passwords remain in one notebook. Other people may help, but they are never given enough knowledge or authority to continue without the founder.

That arrangement can survive for years. It may even look efficient because everyone knows who makes the decisions. Then the founder becomes tired, ill, overwhelmed, disillusioned or simply ready to walk another path. Suddenly the community discovers that it was not standing around a shared hearth. It was standing around someone else’s campfire.

When that person leaves, the flame goes with them.

This is not necessarily the result of selfishness. Founders often keep doing everything because no one else volunteers, because explaining a task takes longer than doing it, or because previous attempts to share responsibility ended badly. A person may carry something alone for so long that they stop noticing how much of its structure exists only inside their own memory.

Eventually, however, a community project must become larger than its founder if it is going to become an inheritance.

Legacy Begins Where Control Ends

We often confuse legacy with control. We imagine preserving someone’s legacy means freezing their creation at the moment they last touched it. Nothing may be moved, questioned, repaired or reinterpreted because “that is how the founder wanted it.” The founder’s name becomes a kind of permanent veto held over people who must live with circumstances the founder never encountered.

That is not legacy. That is embalming.

A living tradition cannot remain exactly as it was. New people arrive. Language changes. Problems emerge. Communities learn things that their founders did not know. A project that cannot respond to any of this may preserve its original shape, but it will do so in the manner of an abandoned building. The walls remain while the life inside them disappears.

Real legacy is what remains after control has been released. It is found in the people who learned how to carry the work, the records that allow its history to be remembered and the values strong enough to survive examination. It is also found in the freedom of later stewards to repair what no longer works.

The successor’s responsibility is not to impersonate the founder. It is to understand what was entrusted to them, preserve what remains valuable and make the changes necessary for the work to continue. That may mean taking it in directions the founder never imagined.

The original log does not remain forever in the hearth. It gives its heat to the next piece of wood.

When the Torch Is Passed

The Heathen Underground provides one version of succession. A founder trusted another person to take responsibility for an existing public project. The name continued, the audience remained and the work developed under different stewardship. Whatever private conversations or practical arrangements accompanied that transition are not ours to invent. What is visible is that there was a handoff and that the project continued afterward.

Declaration 127 shows the more difficult version. The declaration survived as an idea even when the structure maintaining it did not. Its committee burned out. Its website disappeared. The words continued to circulate, but there was no longer an active body maintaining the signatories, answering questions or deciding how the declaration should evolve.

That gap matters. A document may be copied indefinitely, but stewardship involves more than keeping a page online. Someone must maintain the archive, answer for changes, examine whether signatories still live by the principles they endorsed and decide what happens when the community outgrows the original wording.

The Troth accepted that responsibility in 2024. That does not make The Troth the owner of inclusive Heathenry or the final authority over every person who invokes Hávamál 127. It means the organization accepted responsibility for carrying one particular piece of modern Heathen history forward. The declaration gained a home, a visible steward and the possibility of continued development.

The important word here is not ownership. It is responsibility.

The Unseen Structure of Community

Pagan communities are often uncomfortable with structure. Many of us arrived here after leaving institutions that had too much authority, too many rules or too little room for individual experience. Informality can feel like freedom. We gather around a fire, share the work and tell ourselves that no one is really in charge.

Yet someone still owns the account. Someone controls the mailing list. Someone knows where the records are stored. Someone decides who may post, who receives a key, who handles the money and whose version of the story becomes the official memory.

Undefined authority does not disappear. It merely becomes harder to see and more difficult to challenge.

A project does not necessarily need a corporation, a board or a shelf full of bylaws. Its structure should fit its size and purpose. It does, however, need to know who is responsible for what and what happens if that person can no longer do it. Even a small group can keep shared records, provide more than one trusted person with access, document recurring tasks and teach others how the work is done.

That is not bureaucracy for its own sake. It is care for the people who would otherwise inherit confusion.

The Cost of Having No Successor

When no one has been prepared to continue the work, the burden often falls upon whoever happens to be standing closest when the founder leaves. That person receives the public expectations without the knowledge, resources or authority required to meet them. They may not know which bills must be paid, who owns the photographs, where agreements were stored or why certain decisions were made.

The community may then blame the successor for failing to reproduce work that previously depended upon years of invisible knowledge. Alternatively, the project may simply disappear. Its social-media page becomes quiet, its website expires and its history survives as fragments in search results and personal recollections.

This is where volunteer exhaustion becomes more than an administrative problem. It becomes an ethical one. If a community continually depends upon people sacrificing themselves to keep it alive, then it is consuming its caretakers as fuel.

We are usually very good at thanking the person tending the fire. We are less skilled at noticing when they have been standing there alone for twelve hours and no one has brought them water.

Preparing the Next Firekeeper

Succession begins long before someone announces that they are leaving. It begins when knowledge is shared instead of guarded. It begins when another person is allowed to perform the task imperfectly and learn from doing it. It begins when records are kept, decisions are explained and authority is made visible.

It also requires founders to accept that their successors will not do everything the same way. If every difference is treated as betrayal, then no successor can ever truly assume stewardship. They can only serve as a caretaker under the permanent shadow of someone who is no longer carrying the daily burden.

Successors have obligations as well. Taking responsibility for an existing project does not grant permission to erase the people who built it. Change should not require pretending that the earlier work never happened. The names, labour, mistakes and contributions of those who came before remain part of the story.

Healthy succession holds both truths at once: the founder deserves to be remembered, and the successor must be allowed to lead.

There should also be permission for an honourable ending. Not every project must survive forever. Sometimes the responsible choice is to preserve its records, explain why the work is ending and close the door carefully. An honest ending protects more memory than leaving an abandoned page to slowly disappear without explanation.

What Are We Actually Building?

This rabbit reaches beyond The Heathen Underground and Declaration 127. It reaches every Pagan gathering, archive, teaching circle, festival, grove, kindred, website and piece of community land. It reaches anything built by people who quietly assume there will always be someone available to carry it tomorrow.

If a project cannot continue without one particular person, then it has not yet become a community inheritance. It remains a personal undertaking supported by a community. There is nothing inherently wrong with that, provided everyone understands the distinction.

But if we say we are building something for the generations that follow, then we must build doors that other hands can open. We must leave maps, records, tools and room for those who come next to add something of their own.

Founding is an act of creation. Stewardship is an act of endurance. Succession is an act of trust.

The work outlives its founder when the founder is no longer required to stand at its centre, when the successor does not need to erase the founder to find their own place and when the community understands that responsibility belongs to more than the person currently holding the keys.

Somewhere beyond the gate, a new firekeeper is adding wood to a flame they did not start. They are not stealing the fire. They are fulfilling the reason it was lit.

There goes the rabbit again. Godspeed.


Sources and Further Reading

A Gate Is Not a Village: What Comes After Declaration 127

Wooden gate opening onto a forest campfire gathering with people and rabbit

Some rabbit trails bring us back to a place we have already visited, but they do not always bring us back for the same reason. Sometimes the old gate is still standing, but something has changed on the other side.

Unplugged Pagan has already spent considerable time with Declaration 127. We have looked at its origins, its relationship to Hávamál 127, its opposition to folkism, its expansion into Declaration 127 2.0, and what its teaching about frith means when the problem is not a stranger outside the hall but someone already sitting near the fire. Those earlier posts asked where the line should be drawn and why silence should not be confused with peace.

This is not another walk through the same history. The rabbit has moved past the sign at the gate and is now looking at what stands behind it. Declaration 127 helped Inclusive Heathens identify what they would no longer tolerate, but a community cannot live forever on a list of things it opposes. Once the gate has been built, someone still has to build the village.

The Gate Was Necessary

The original Declaration 127 appeared in 2016 as a direct response to the Ásatrú Folk Assembly and its exclusionary claims about race, sexuality and gender. Its purpose was narrow but important: the signatories would not promote, associate with or conduct business with the AFA while those policies remained in place. They would not offer the silent approval of frið to people using Heathen traditions to justify prejudice.

That first declaration was a gate. It said that not every ideology using Heathen names, symbols and gods would automatically receive recognition as an equally legitimate form of Heathenry. It rejected the idea that hospitality required giving racial exclusion an honoured seat in the hall.

Declaration 127 2.0 widened that gate in 2021. Instead of concentrating on one named organization, it addressed discrimination more broadly and included age, ability, health, race, ethnicity, ancestry, veteran status, gender, gender identity, sexuality and socioeconomic class. The Declaration of Deeds, which emerged around the same period, added a particularly Heathen answer: the circumstances of birth do not establish a person’s worth. Deeds do.

Those were necessary developments. A village with no gate cannot protect the people inside it. Hospitality without boundaries is not hospitality for long, because eventually the person who wants to control the hall will make everyone else unsafe. The gate matters, and the people who insisted on building it were not wrong.

But a gate is still not a village.

A gate cannot feed the hungry, teach the inexperienced, conduct ritual, preserve memory, care for the grieving or settle a dispute fairly. It can tell us who should not be permitted to poison the well, but it cannot by itself tell us how the well will be maintained, who will carry the water or what happens when the keeper of the well is the person causing harm.

When a Declaration Becomes a Rule

This is where something genuinely new has happened. In January 2026, The Troth adopted formal codes of conduct for its members and leaders. These standards prohibit discrimination, harassment, retaliation, misuse of authority and institutional bullying. They also protect good-faith reporting and begin laying out reporting processes, safeguards against conflicts of interest, due process and avenues of appeal.

One provision deserves particular attention from an Unplugged Pagan perspective: leaders are specifically forbidden from weaponizing frith to pressure harmed people into silence, forced reconciliation or simply “being nice.”

That is a significant step beyond placing a declaration on a website. It recognizes that sacred language can itself be used as a tool of control. Words such as frith, hospitality, kinship, loyalty and community can describe worthy obligations, but they can also be turned against the injured person. A leader can invoke peace while protecting the person who broke it. A community can demand reconciliation before truth has been established. A hall can preserve its reputation by convincing the wounded person that speaking publicly would be the greater betrayal.

Unplugged Pagan has called that false peace. The Troth has now given that problem an organizational name and placed it inside a leadership standard. Frith is not protected by silencing the person who reports harm. Frith was already damaged by the act that made the report necessary.

This is the movement from moral language to accountable structure. A declaration says, “We oppose harm.” A code of conduct asks what happens when harm occurs, who receives the complaint, what protects the complainant from retaliation, how evidence is considered, how conflicts of interest are handled and whether the person making the decision can also be questioned.

That may sound administrative rather than spiritual, but healthy structure is one of the ways a community practices care. When authority is left informal and undefined, authority does not disappear. It simply becomes harder to see, harder to challenge and easier to misuse.

The People Carrying the Declaration

There is another lesson in what happened to Declaration 127 after version 2.0 was released. By the end of 2021, its volunteer committee had burned out and the original website eventually became inaccessible. The declaration survived in archives and through organizations that had signed it, but the structure responsible for maintaining the document, vetting signatories and answering questions largely disappeared.

This was not proof that the declaration had failed. It was proof that good intentions still require sustainable labour. Pagan communities repeatedly build important things on the backs of a few volunteers, celebrate the result and then quietly expect those same people to carry it indefinitely. When those people become exhausted, the disappearance of the work is often treated as a personal failure rather than the predictable result of an unsupported structure.

A village cannot be maintained by praising the firekeeper while leaving that person alone to gather every piece of wood.

In April 2024, responsibility for Declaration 127 and its associated assets was transferred to The Troth. The organization created a Declaration 127 subcommittee within its Community Relations Committee, giving the document a more permanent institutional home. That does not make The Troth the owner of Inclusive Heathenry, nor does it make the organization beyond criticism. It does, however, create identifiable responsibility for preserving the declaration and continuing its development.

In February 2026, The Troth announced an Inclusive Heathen coalition involving The Asatru Community, Fellowship of Fire and Ice, Heathens Against Hate and Urglaawe International. The coalition began working on a new shared position statement addressing the future of Declaration 127. A month later, The Troth reported that a new working draft was nearing release and would be opened to community comment and further revision.

At the time of writing, I have not found that draft publicly available. That means the work should not be treated as finished. The coalition is evidence of movement, not proof of completion. What ultimately matters will be the wording of the new document, the process used to revise it, the way signatories are vetted and what participating organizations are actually expected to do when those principles are violated.

Can Opposition Hold a Community Together?

A new Canadian academic study adds another important question. In his 2026 University of Ottawa thesis, Inclusive Heathenry: The Use of German Pagan Rhetoric in the Construction of a Progressive Contemporary Religion, David Gerald Joseph O’Reilly treats Declaration 127 as a turning point. It helped move Heathenry beyond the older language of “universalism” and toward an Inclusive Heathen identity that actively confronts racism and celebrates racial, sexual and gender diversity.

O’Reilly also raises a difficult criticism. Since 2016, much of Inclusive Heathenry’s energy has been directed toward separating itself from racist or otherwise harmful forms of Heathenry. That separation was necessary, but opposition can become an incomplete foundation. If the loudest shared conversation is always about who must be removed, the community may never develop a sufficiently strong answer to why everyone else should remain.

This does not mean anti-racism has become unnecessary or that the gate should be taken down. A village that forgets why the gate was built will eventually invite the same danger back inside. The question is whether defending the boundary has become the community’s entire identity.

People do not join a religious community only because it has expelled the correct people. They remain because they find ritual, meaning, relationship, obligation, teaching, care, memory and a place where their presence matters. They need more than safety from exclusion. They need belonging.

That distinction is important. Inclusion says that you may enter. Belonging says that your presence changes the shape of the village. Inclusion gives you a seat beside the fire. Belonging means someone notices when you are missing, listens when you speak, values what you contribute and helps carry you when your own strength fails.

What Must Be Built Inside the Gate?

If Declaration 127 marks the boundary, the next stage of Inclusive Heathenry must be measured by what it builds within that boundary. That includes rituals people can share without surrendering the diversity of their individual paths. It includes education grounded in responsible scholarship rather than fantasy history, clergy and community leaders trained to recognize harm, processes that allow complaints without retaliation, and archives that preserve community memory beyond the lifespan of one website or administrator.

It also includes ordinary forms of reciprocity. Visiting the sick. Helping someone through grief. Teaching a newcomer how to make an offering without making them feel foolish. Sharing food. Maintaining sacred places. Supporting people in recovery. Making gatherings accessible. Remembering the volunteers after the event posters come down. Allowing someone to leave without treating departure as betrayal.

None of those things is as dramatic as publishing a declaration. They are also the things that determine whether the declaration means anything.

The Declaration of Deeds gave us the simplest version of this lesson: we are known by what we do. An organization may describe itself as inclusive, but the word must eventually be visible in budgets, policies, accessibility, leadership choices, disciplinary processes, rituals and daily relationships. Otherwise, “inclusive” becomes another decorative label placed over the door.

The same is true of frith. If frith exists only when nobody complains, it is not frith. If hospitality exists only for people who never challenge authority, it is not hospitality. If belonging lasts only while a person remains useful, agreeable and silent, it is not belonging.

The Work After the Declaration

Our earlier UP posts concluded that declarations are not wards. They do not banish harm through correct wording, and they do not replace the courage required to act when the problem arrives at the hearth. The developments of 2026 do not invalidate that conclusion. They show what must come next.

The conduct codes give the boundary practical form. The coalition distributes some of the responsibility across multiple organizations. The proposed revision opens the possibility of community participation. The new scholarship asks whether Inclusive Heathenry can build a religious culture strong enough to offer more than opposition.

None of this guarantees success. Policies can be ignored. Committees can become closed circles. Reporting systems can protect institutions instead of people. Coalitions can produce statements nobody enforces. A beautiful village plan can remain rolled up on a table while the roof continues to leak.

Still, there is something important in recognizing that the gate was never supposed to be the finished work. Declaration 127 was a necessary refusal. It said that racial exclusion, white supremacy and other forms of dehumanizing discrimination would not be granted silence in the name of peace. The task now is to build a community in which that refusal is expressed through protection, accountability, shared practice and meaningful belonging.

A gate tells us where the village begins. Deeds tell us whether a village actually exists.

The rabbit has passed beneath the sign and found plans spread across a table under the trees. The walls are not complete, the new declaration has not yet arrived, and some of the old work still needs repair. But the question is finally moving in the right direction. It is no longer only, “What are we standing against?” It is becoming, “What are we responsible for building together?”

There goes the rabbit again. Godspeed.


Sources and Further Reading

The Rabbit Finds the Heathen Underground

Rabbit sitting beneath enormous tree roots in a forest with a distant campfire

Sometimes the rabbit does not lead us farther into the forest. Sometimes it finds a hole beneath the roots and asks us to look at what has been growing underground all along.

This particular rabbit began with a simple question: What is The Heathen Underground, and does it exist anywhere beyond Facebook?

At first glance, the answer appears straightforward. The Heathen Underground is a large Facebook presence devoted to Heathen beliefs, history and practice. It has a public Facebook Page followed by nearly forty-eight thousand people, along with a separate discussion space called The Heathen Underground Community.

The Page is the publication. The group is the gathering place.

But rabbits are rarely satisfied with the first answer.

Two Doors Bearing the Same Name

The public Page operates less like a congregation and more like a Heathen newspaper, library and community bulletin board rolled together. It shares archaeology, anthropology, folklore, medieval history, books, art, music, ritual practices and discussions about what Heathenry means in the modern world. Some of the material is original, but much of it is carefully selected from researchers, historians, artists and other Heathen or Pagan creators.

The accompanying Community group is where people are invited to discuss those subjects with one another. One door distributes information; the other invites conversation.

The name “underground” may suggest secrecy, but very little about the project is hidden. Its positions are public, its administrators sign their posts, and its community standards are unusually direct. The Heathen Underground describes itself as inclusive, states that marginalized people are active and valued members of the community, and warns that discrimination will result in removal.

It is also openly opposed to folkish Heathenry, racial gatekeeping, white nationalism and attempts to use Germanic religion as a vehicle for far-right politics. The Page is listed among the online supporters of Declaration 127, the Heathen declaration opposing the normalization of racism and white supremacy within Heathen spaces.

This means The Heathen Underground is not pretending to be politically neutral. Its administrators appear to believe that deciding who may stand around the community fire is itself a religious and ethical question. The gods, the ancestors and the old stories may be central, but so is the treatment of the living person standing beside you.

The Roots Beneath the Page

The project has also changed hands over time.

The available public record identifies Heather O’Brien as its founder. In late summer 2017, when the original Page was apparently in danger of being deleted, responsibility for it was passed to Nicole Butler. More recent posts identify Nicole, Æsc and Sophia as the people tending it.

That history matters. Online communities often look permanent because the name and profile picture remain the same. Behind the screen, however, stewardship changes. Founders leave. New caretakers arrive. Editorial priorities evolve. A Page can retain its name while becoming a different expression of the community that inherited it.

That does not necessarily make the later version false or illegitimate. It makes the Page a living tradition rather than a frozen artifact.

There is an interesting parallel here with Pagan land and Pagan gatherings. A place may keep its old name while the people maintaining it change. A festival may continue while its purpose gradually shifts. A community may speak of continuity even though the hands carrying the work are no longer the hands that began it.

The name survives, but the meaning is continually being renewed by whoever holds responsibility for it.

The Trail Returns to Raven’s Knoll

Then the rabbit crossed a trail we have followed before.

A 2023 academic article in Nova Religio, “Inclusive Heathens Practice Ancestor Veneration, But Not Pride in Ancestry,” identifies Nicole Butler as the host of The Heathen Underground and as a gythia active within the Heathen community of Raven’s Knoll. Æsc Adams is also identified in related research as her partner and cohost.

That places The Heathen Underground within a recognizable Ontario Heathen network involving religious practice, online education, community gatherings and Raven’s Knoll.

This is where we have to resist turning an ordinary network into an extraordinary theory.

Shared people, places and projects do not prove common ownership, hidden control or secret coordination. Small religious communities naturally develop overlapping networks. The same person may help organize a ritual, administer a Facebook group, contribute to a gathering, write a book and sit for an academic interview. That is not evidence of a conspiracy. It is often simply what community labour looks like when the community is small and the number of people willing to perform that labour is smaller still.

What the connection does show is that The Heathen Underground is not merely an anonymous content farm passing around Viking pictures. It is connected to people engaged in lived Heathen practice and to one of the better-documented Heathen environments in Canada.

For those who know the history of Raven’s Knoll, this should not be surprising. The land has long been a meeting point where different paths overlap: Pagan, Heathen, Druidic, polytheist, festival, academic and increasingly nonreligious. People arrive through different gates, but many of their paths eventually cross beneath the same trees.

Who Keeps the Memory?

This is where the rabbit became more interesting.

The Heathen Underground is not simply sharing information. It is helping decide what contemporary Heathens encounter, what stories remain visible, which sources are treated as credible and what behaviour is publicly rejected. When it shares an archaeological discovery, it contributes to religious education. When it promotes a book, it helps determine which voices are heard. When it denounces racism or abuse, it helps establish the boundaries of acceptable community conduct.

That makes it part of Heathen memory.

Not the whole memory. Not an unquestionable memory. But one of the places where memory is collected, sorted and passed forward.

We often imagine community memory as stories told beside a fire. Today, some of those fires are digital. The storytellers are Page administrators, the audience is counted in followers, and the circle is governed partly by an algorithm belonging to a corporation with no particular obligation to Heathenry, Paganism or the preservation of either.

That creates an uncomfortable question. What happens when a substantial portion of a religious community’s public memory lives on a platform that can change its rules, hide old material or delete the entire archive?

The Heathen Underground has a confirmed account on X under the name @OriginalHU, although its publicly indexed activity appears old. There is also a small YouTube channel bearing the same name, but I could not conclusively establish that it belongs to the same administrators. A 2017 book by Æsc Adams was published through Hart’s Horn Press, described by its Amazon listing as a subsidiary of The Heathen Underground.

Beyond those tracks, there does not appear to be an active independent website, public archive or substantial presence on newer social platforms. Facebook is not simply one branch of The Heathen Underground. Facebook is effectively where The Heathen Underground lives.

Its influence beyond Facebook is visible mainly through other people referring back to it. The Longship recommends it as a Heathen resource. The Wild Hunt reported on its role in publicly confronting racist and threatening behaviour in 2021. Academic researchers have interviewed its hosts and treated the Page as a recognizable part of modern inclusive Heathenry.

Its roots extend beyond Facebook, but its trunk remains planted firmly inside it.

What the Rabbit Found

The rabbit did not uncover a secret organization beneath the forest floor. It found something both simpler and more important: roots.

The Heathen Underground is a public-facing expression of an interconnected Heathen community. It is part educational resource, part editorial platform, part political boundary marker and part community gathering place. Its history reaches from its original American founder to later Canadian stewardship, and from an online Page into the lived Heathen landscape surrounding Raven’s Knoll.

That does not mean every person at Raven’s Knoll speaks through it. It does not mean every inclusive Heathen agrees with it. It does not make the Page the official voice of Canadian Heathenry. It means only that it has become one of the more visible places where certain strands of modern Heathen identity, scholarship, politics and community memory meet.

Perhaps that is what an underground really is.

Not a hidden room where plans are made, but the unseen network beneath the forest: roots touching roots, carrying nourishment, memory and warning from one part of the community to another.

The Page is what we see above the soil. The relationships are what keep it alive beneath.

There goes the rabbit again. Godspeed.


A note on scope: This post follows publicly available sources and documented relationships. Shared people, venues, terminology or projects demonstrate connection, but they do not by themselves establish common ownership, control, wrongdoing or secret coordination.

Embracing the Full Moon: A Personal Reflection

Candlelit stone circle surrounded by flowers in a moonlit forest

I thought the full moon was last night.

Turns out I was a little early.

Tonight, August 27 into the early hours of August 28, the Moon is not only full, it is passing almost completely into the shadow of the Earth.

Here in Ontario, the penumbral eclipse begins this evening, the obvious partial eclipse begins around 10:33 p.m., and maximum eclipse arrives shortly after midnight. According to NASA, at the deepest point of the eclipse, about 96.3 percent of the Moon’s disk will be inside the Earth’s umbra.

Almost total.

But not quite.

And somehow I think that makes it more interesting.

Maybe understanding the machinery does not remove the mystery.

We know what is happening. The Earth is passing between the Sun and the Moon. The Earth blocks the sunlight that normally illuminates the Moon. Some of that sunlight filters through our atmosphere, which can give the shadowed Moon that familiar copper or reddish appearance.

No dragon is eating it.

No deity has stolen it.

The Moon has not died.

There is no cosmic battle taking place above us.

And yet, if you walk outside tonight and actually look up, knowing all of that does not make the sight any less extraordinary.

That got me thinking about something larger.

Where exactly does the sacred come from?

The Moon Does Not Need Our Mythology

Modern Paganism has developed an enormous collection of lunar correspondences. Full moons have names, colours, herbs, crystals, intentions, gods, goddesses, rituals and recommended magical workings attached to them.

Some come from old traditions. Some come from particular cultures. Some are modern constructions. Some appear to have originated approximately fifteen minutes before somebody turned them into an infographic.

That does not automatically make every modern practice meaningless. Religions have always developed, borrowed, adapted and changed.

But occasionally I wonder whether we become so busy assigning meaning to nature that we forget to experience nature.

The Moon tonight does not require me to assign a correspondence to it.

I do not need a particular coloured candle.

I do not need the correct crystal.

I do not need to know which herbs supposedly correspond with an August lunar eclipse.

I can simply walk outside.

Look up.

And watch the shadow of the planet I am standing on slowly move across another world.

That alone is pretty damned magical.

And Apparently Humans Have Been Doing This for a Very Long Time

Interestingly enough, while I was looking around the Pagan web for something worth discussing tonight, The Wild Hunt published a story about archaeological research in the Czech Republic.

Researchers studying a prehistoric enclosure near Chleby believe people living there more than 6,500 years ago constructed a large ritual space whose entrances were deliberately oriented toward movements of the Sun and Moon.

The site predates the major prehistoric construction at Stonehenge by more than a thousand years.

The enclosure is enormous, roughly 230 metres across, surrounded by a deep ditch and broken by a dozen entrances. Researchers studying the geometry of those entrances have identified alignments associated with important solar and lunar cycles, including the solstices and extreme positions in the Moon’s long cycle across the horizon.

There is also evidence suggesting that the place was more than an astronomical measuring device. Animal remains, including cattle skulls and horns, were found around portions of the enclosure, and the site appears to have been used for ritual and communal purposes.

We should be careful here.

These people were not Wiccans.

They were not Druids in the modern sense.

They were not Heathens.

We cannot simply reach six thousand years into the past, grab whatever looks vaguely familiar and declare, “See? Pagans.”

We do not know exactly what they believed.

But we can see what they did.

They watched the sky.

They watched the seasons.

They noticed patterns.

They gathered.

They built.

And apparently the movements of the Sun and Moon mattered enough that generations of human beings invested significant labour into physically marking those movements on the landscape.

That interests me far more than trying to claim them as members of some modern Pagan tradition.

Thousands of years later, I can walk outside in Ontario and look at the same Moon.

Different culture. Different language. Different religion. Different understanding of the universe.

Same sky.

Then We Invented the Internet

Which brings us to another recent piece from The Wild Hunt.

A guest essay published earlier this month argued for the importance of in-person connection within Pagan and occult communities. The author described an online environment increasingly shaped by echo chambers, manufactured outrage and division, and suggested that physical gatherings can build relationships capable of surviving disagreement in ways that online interaction often does not.

This one struck a nerve with me.

Because those of us who remember Pagan community before social media remember something that is very easy to forget.

You sometimes had to deal with people you disagreed with.

In person.

Imagine that.

You could disagree with somebody about theology in the afternoon and still need their help putting up a dining shelter before the rain arrived.

You could think somebody’s interpretation of a tradition was completely backwards and still sit beside them at the fire that night.

The person who irritated the living hell out of you might also be the person holding the other end of the tent pole.

Or carrying water.

Or cooking dinner.

Or watching the fire.

Or helping when something went wrong.

That changes relationships.

It does not eliminate conflict. Pagan communities have never lacked conflict, politics, personality clashes or spectacular explosions of human stupidity.

But physical community forces us to encounter the whole human being.

Social media often reduces that same person to the one sentence we disagree with.

Then the algorithm discovers that our anger keeps us scrolling.

And suddenly disagreement becomes entertainment.

So Pagans Are Trying to Reinvent the Village

Another curious thing I stumbled across is a relatively new social platform called FolkRealms.

It describes itself as a human-powered community for people interested in Paganism, Heathenry, mythology, folk traditions and related subjects. What caught my attention was not simply that somebody built another Pagan social network.

We’ve seen Pagan forums, email lists, message boards, social networks and communities come and go before.

What interested me was what FolkRealms says it does not want.

No advertising.

No algorithm deciding what keeps you sufficiently angry to remain on the platform.

No bots.

No AI-generated content.

The stated intention is real people talking to real people.

Whether that particular experiment succeeds in the long term remains to be seen. Creating a platform is easy compared with creating a healthy community. Eventually every community has to answer the difficult questions: who belongs, who decides, how disagreement is handled, what behaviour is acceptable, and what happens when two people’s definitions of community collide.

Those problems existed around fires long before broadband.

Technology simply changes the size and speed of the argument.

Still, the fact that people are deliberately looking for online spaces without algorithms, bots and artificial content tells us something.

Maybe people are getting tired of being processed.

Which Brings Us to AI Writing Pagan Books

This is where tonight’s little journey through the Pagan web becomes particularly strange.

The Wild Hunt also reported this week on an investigation into potentially AI-generated religious books being sold through Amazon.

The investigation examined 2,034 books in Amazon’s Religion & Spirituality category, mostly published during the first half of 2026.

The researchers estimated that 63 percent of the books examined were likely AI-generated.

Among books categorized around Witchcraft, the estimate was 78 percent.

Seventy-eight percent.

Now, there is a very important qualification here.

AI detectors are not infallible.

They can produce false positives. Different writing styles can trigger them. Researchers themselves acknowledge limitations in using detection tools.

So we should absolutely not turn that number into the claim that “78 percent of Witchcraft books are definitely written by AI.”

That is not what the research establishes.

But even with that caution, the findings raise a rather uncomfortable question.

What happens when Paganism starts being taught by authors who may never have practised Paganism at all?

That concerns me more than the existence of artificial intelligence itself.

Because there is an important distinction that tends to disappear whenever we discuss AI.

A human being can use a tool.

A writer can bring decades of experience, memories, research, arguments, mistakes, conversations and lived practice to a piece of writing and use technology to organize information, check grammar, compare sources or help shape material.

The experience is still coming from somewhere.

That is very different from typing:

“Write me a complete book about ancient Celtic full moon magic.”

And then selling whatever comes out under the name of an author who never existed.

The machine has never stood beneath a full moon.

It has never tended a ritual fire.

It has never disagreed with somebody across that fire and had to work beside them the next morning.

It has never buried a friend.

It has never watched a festival site change over twenty years.

It has never felt rain arrive halfway through ritual.

It has never sat alone in the woods wondering whether the gods are listening.

It has never had the experience of suddenly realizing that something you believed twenty years ago no longer makes sense.

It can process descriptions of those things.

It cannot have them.

Maybe That Is the Thread Connecting All of This

Tonight the Earth is casting its shadow across the Moon.

More than six thousand years ago, people built a massive ritual enclosure that appears to have helped them track the movements of that same sky.

Today Pagan writers are worrying about losing lived spiritual experience to machine-generated books.

Other Pagans are worrying that online interaction has replaced human community.

And still others are attempting to build digital spaces where algorithms and artificial content are deliberately excluded.

Those stories initially looked completely unrelated.

I don’t think they are.

They are all asking the same question.

Where does meaning actually come from?

Maybe it comes from participation.

Watching instead of merely reading about watching.

Doing instead of endlessly consuming instructions about doing.

Gathering instead of merely following.

Remembering instead of allowing an algorithm to decide what history appears in our feed.

Learning from people while remembering that people are fallible.

Using tools without allowing the tools to become substitutes for experience.

Perhaps that is something modern Paganism needs to think seriously about.

We have more Pagan information available to us today than at any other point in modern history.

Books. Podcasts. YouTube. Websites. Archives. Academic papers. Social networks. Digital libraries. Artificial intelligence.

And yet information is not necessarily wisdom.

A correspondence chart is not a relationship with the Moon.

A Facebook group is not automatically a community.

A book is not automatically tradition.

An ancient archaeological site is not automatically evidence for whatever modern belief we would like it to support.

And technology is neither automatically our salvation nor automatically our enemy.

They’re tools.

The question is what we do with them.

Meanwhile, There Is an Eclipse Happening

And after wandering through 6,500 years of human history, Pagan community, archaeology, artificial intelligence and the future of spiritual publishing, I find myself coming back to where this started.

The Moon.

Tonight I don’t particularly need somebody to tell me what the eclipse is supposed to mean.

I think I’d rather look at it.

Because perhaps one of the oldest Pagan practices available to us is also one of the simplest.

Pay attention.

To the sky.

To the land.

To the people around the fire.

To the stories being handed to us.

To who wrote them.

To what is real.

To what we merely want to be real.

And every now and then, put the damned screen down and look up.

The Moon was here long before Pagan social media.

It was here long before our books.

It was here long before Stonehenge.

And tonight the shadow of the Earth is slowly moving across it.

That seems worth stepping outside for.


Sources and further reading: NASA Scientific Visualization Studio, August 27–28, 2026 Deep Partial Lunar Eclipse; Timeanddate, August 28, 2026 Partial Lunar Eclipse in Ottawa, Ontario; The Wild Hunt, Study Reports AI-Generated Books Flood Witchcraft and Religious Publishing; The Wild Hunt, A Thousand Years Before Stonehenge: Ancient Czech Sanctuary Tracked Sun and Moon; The Wild Hunt, Ecumenical Occulture: The Importance of In-Person Connection; FolkRealms, About FolkRealms.

Why Is a Viking Group in Manitoba Named After an Irish God?

Festival-goers raise hands beneath a Hiberno-Norse Heritage Festival sign

Well, this is what happens when you chase rabbits.

I was digging into Íslendingadagurinn, the Icelandic Festival of Manitoba held in Gimli, because it had wandered into another question I’ve been asking lately: what survives when a religion disappears but a culture keeps remembering? Íslendingadagurinn is not a Pagan festival. It is an Icelandic-Canadian cultural festival with roots going back to 1890, and yet within it we find sagas, Viking history, folklore, old imagery and a reconstructed Viking Village. Then, buried rather innocently on the official Viking Village page, I noticed the name of the living-history group helping make that village happen.

Hands of Lugh.

Hang on.

Lugh?

Not Odin. Not Thor. Not Freyr. Not Tyr.

Lugh.

One of the great figures of the old Irish mythological tradition.

So why, in the middle of an Icelandic festival in Gimli, Manitoba, is a Viking living-history organization carrying the name of an Irish god?

At first glance it looks like one of those wonderful historical mismatches that modern Paganism produces from time to time: Celtic thing over here, Norse thing over there, someone likes both, mash them together and carry on. Except the deeper I went, the less mismatched it became. In fact, the problem may not be Hands of Lugh at all.

The problem may be the filing cabinets we use to organize history.

First, Who Are Hands of Lugh?

Hands of Lugh describes itself quite simply as “Viking Age Living History.” This isn’t just a bunch of people putting on horned helmets and beating on shields for tourists. In fact, their own authenticity guidelines specifically prohibit horned helmets, along with a number of other things that belong more to modern Viking fantasy than the archaeological record.

The group reconstructs aspects of Viking Age life through clothing, cooking, textiles, metalworking, woodworking, archery, slings, combat and other everyday skills. Their material is researched, recreated and then actually used within a living-history setting. At Íslendingadagurinn, the Icelandic Festival’s own Viking Village page says its reenactors have spent thousands of hours researching and recreating objects from the period. Hands of Lugh is named directly as a partner in that village.

And this isn’t their only appearance. Hands of Lugh also turns up at Manitoba heritage events, Highland gatherings, medieval festivals and the Gimli Ice Festival. An older Manitoba Highland Gathering page identifies the group as “formerly called Sons of Lugh.” So the name isn’t some recent branding choice created specifically for Íslendingadagurinn. Lugh has apparently been along for the ride for quite some time.

That older name gives us another little breadcrumb. Search around the group’s older presence online and you will find references to the Sons of Lugh associated with Hiberno-Norse or Norse-Gaelic reenactment. But we don’t even have to depend entirely on old social-media descriptions to make the Irish connection, because the current Hands of Lugh authenticity guide tells us exactly what historical world they are interested in reconstructing.

And this is where the rabbit gets interesting.

Look at Their Map, Not Just Their Name

The Hands of Lugh Authenticity Guide says that a core objective of the Viking Village is an accurate portrayal of the later Viking Age with a particular focus on Iceland. Fair enough. We are standing in New Iceland, at an Icelandic festival. You would expect Iceland.

But then they explain where they look for material evidence.

The guide says objects should generally reflect Viking Age northwestern Europe, particularly the western diaspora, and actually gives examples: Hedeby, York and Dublin. Their preferred period is roughly 950–1000 CE. Icelandic archaeological material is considered ideal, but because surviving Icelandic finds can be fragmentary, they draw carefully from related places within that western Viking world.

There it is.

Dublin.

Suddenly the Irish name on the Viking group isn’t sitting quite so awkwardly anymore.

Because the Viking Age was not a neat little Scandinavian box.

The Vikings Went to Ireland — And Then Ireland Happened to Them

The first recorded Viking raids on Ireland occurred near the end of the eighth century. Raiding eventually became settlement. Dublin became a fortified Viking base in the ninth century, while Dublin, Waterford, Limerick, Cork and Wexford developed into major centres of Viking settlement and trade. According to the National Museum of Ireland, these settlements helped create Ireland’s first towns and profoundly altered Irish economic and cultural life.

But cultures have a bad habit of refusing to remain separate once human beings actually start living beside one another.

Norse settlers traded with Irish people. They fought Irish people. Irish kings allied with Norse rulers. Norse rulers allied with Irish kings. People married. Children were born. Languages rubbed against each other. Clothing, jewellery, technology, art and stories crossed boundaries. Eventually there were people who could no longer be described particularly well by saying simply “Irish” or “Norse.”

They are commonly called Hiberno-Norse or Norse-Gaels.

Heritage Ireland describes the Hiberno-Norse as emerging from Irish-Norse relationships and mixed communities beginning during the Viking Age. These were people growing up inside cultural households that could contain both Irish and Norse influences. The National Museum goes even further into the archaeological problem: by the end of the tenth century, as Viking communities in Ireland adopted Christianity and the cultures increasingly fused, it can sometimes become difficult to tell whether an object should even be classified as Viking or Irish.

Think about that for a moment.

We like our labels.

Celtic.

Norse.

Irish.

Icelandic.

Viking.

Heathen.

Separate shelves. Separate books. Separate pantheons. Separate symbols.

The archaeological record basically shrugs at us and says, “Good luck with that.”

And then Hands of Lugh walks into an Icelandic festival carrying the name of an Irish god and accidentally demonstrates the entire problem.

But Why Lugh?

This is where I want to be careful.

I have not found a statement from Hands of Lugh saying, “We chose this name for the following religious or historical reason.” Unless somebody from the organization tells us directly, anything more specific than the evidence allows becomes speculation.

But the choice is certainly interesting.

Lugh — Lug in older Irish material — appears prominently in Cath Maige Tuired, the Second Battle of Mag Tuired, one of the major surviving texts dealing with the Túatha Dé Danann. The University College Cork Corpus of Electronic Texts provides Elizabeth A. Gray’s translation of the story.

In one of Lugh’s most famous scenes, he arrives at Tara and is stopped by the doorkeeper. He needs to demonstrate that he has something to offer the court.

So Lugh starts listing skills.

Builder.

Smith.

Champion.

Harper.

Warrior.

Poet and historian.

Sorcerer.

Physician.

Cupbearer.

Brazier.

Each time the doorkeeper essentially tells him, “We’ve already got one of those.”

Finally Lugh asks the question that changes everything: do you have one person who possesses all of these arts?

They don’t.

He is admitted.

The text calls him Samildánach, the one skilled in many arts. His importance isn’t that he alone knows how to swing a weapon. It is precisely the opposite. Lugh embodies breadth of skill. Craftsmanship, knowledge, music, medicine, martial ability, leadership and practical competence all exist in the same figure.

Now go back and look at Hands of Lugh.

Metalworking.

Woodworking.

Textiles.

Cooking.

Archery.

Combat.

Historical research.

Reconstruction.

A group of people attempting to recover and demonstrate the many skills required to recreate a functioning slice of Viking Age life.

Does that prove they chose Lugh because he was Samildánach?

No.

But if you were going to choose an Irish mythological figure as the namesake of a hands-on historical-reconstruction group built around mastering many different crafts, you could certainly do worse.

And the later change from Sons of Lugh to Hands of Lugh makes the imagery even better, whether intentionally or accidentally.

These are quite literally the hands doing the work.

The Icelandic Connection Is More Celtic Than We Sometimes Remember

There is another reason we should be careful about imagining Icelandic history as exclusively Scandinavian.

The settlement of Iceland itself involved people from both the Scandinavian world and the British Isles. Modern genetic research has confirmed what historical and genealogical scholarship had long suggested: the founding population of Iceland contained substantial Norse and Gaelic ancestry.

A major ancient-DNA study published in Science examined genomes from Iceland’s early population and found that the founders had both Gaelic and Norse origins. That does not mean “Iceland was secretly Celtic,” any more than finding Norse ancestry in Ireland means “Ireland was secretly Scandinavian.” It means the actual North Atlantic world was connected.

People moved.

And they carried other people with them, sometimes voluntarily and sometimes very much not. We should not romanticize that process. Viking expansion included slavery, captive-taking and violence. Some of the Gaelic presence in Iceland almost certainly came through people taken from Ireland and Britain into Norse-controlled networks. Other movement occurred through marriage, settlement, alliance and migration.

The result, however, was that when Iceland emerged as a distinct society, its human roots did not come solely from Scandinavia.

So when an Iceland-focused historical group looks westward toward Dublin and the Norse-Gaelic world for comparative archaeological material, it isn’t wandering off topic.

It’s following the roads the Vikings themselves travelled.

Maybe “Celtic Versus Norse” Was Always the Wrong Question

This is where I think modern Paganism can learn something from the reenactors.

We have become very good at taxonomy.

This deity belongs to this pantheon. This symbol belongs to that culture. This practice came from these people. This reconstruction belongs on this shelf. Heathenry goes here. Celtic Paganism goes there. Druidry goes over there. Don’t mix the folders.

There are good reasons for some of that. Historical specificity matters. Cultural appropriation matters. Claiming that every European tradition was secretly one universal religion does violence to the differences between those cultures. We shouldn’t erase distinctions merely because it makes our modern spiritual lives tidier.

But going too far in the opposite direction creates another fiction.

People in the past were not museum exhibits.

The Irish Sea was not a wall.

The North Atlantic was not divided by modern national borders.

A ship leaving Norway could touch Scotland, Ireland, the Isle of Man, Iceland and beyond. Dublin was part of a Viking trade network reaching far beyond Ireland. York was another enormous cultural crossroads. Iceland’s settlers carried Scandinavian and Gaelic ancestry. Norse-Gaelic societies emerged precisely because people didn’t remain conveniently inside the categories we later invented for them.

So perhaps the question isn’t:

“Why is there an Irish god in a Viking group?”

Perhaps the better question is:

“Why did we assume the Irish and Viking worlds were separate enough that this should surprise us?”

That’s a much better rabbit.

Then There Is the Question of Religion

There is another distinction worth making because this is Unplugged Pagan and sooner or later somebody is going to ask it.

Does calling the organization Hands of Lugh make it a Pagan group?

Not from anything I can find.

The organization’s public material presents Hands of Lugh as a Viking Age living-history organization. Its website concentrates on historical accuracy, material culture, crafts, combat and education. I have found no statement requiring members to worship Lugh, practice Irish Paganism, follow Heathenry or hold any particular religious belief.

In fact, the group has published a statement called Vikings Against Racism, explicitly rejecting discrimination based on race, religion or gender and pushing back against the racist appropriation of Viking imagery.

That matters.

Because again we encounter this strange territory between religion, history and cultural memory.

Here is the name of an old Irish divine figure being carried by a modern Canadian organization that does not appear to require religious devotion to him.

Lugh’s name survives.

The crafts survive — or are reconstructed.

The stories survive because manuscripts survived.

The Viking material survives because archaeologists dug it out of the ground.

The Hiberno-Norse world survives because historians, museums and researchers piece together the evidence.

Then living historians pick all of this material up with their hands and make it tangible again.

There is something wonderfully appropriate about that.

Reconstruction Is Memory Done Deliberately

This brings us straight back to the rabbit that started this whole thing.

I’ve been asking what happens when communities disappear and what survives when nobody deliberately records their history. Íslendingadagurinn gave us one answer: cultural memory can survive for generations when people continue gathering, telling stories and building institutions around that memory.

Hands of Lugh gives us another.

Sometimes memory isn’t enough.

Sometimes you have to reconstruct.

You find the object.

You read the excavation report.

You compare several finds.

You work out how the thing might have been made.

You discover your first attempt doesn’t work.

You make it again.

You wear the clothing instead of merely looking at it behind glass. You cook with the utensils. You work the metal. You split the wood. You spin the fibre. You carry the shield. You discover which historical assumptions survive contact with actual human hands.

That’s a different form of remembering.

It is remembering through doing.

And there may be something here for modern Paganism that goes beyond Vikings, Ireland or Iceland.

We’ve become very good at preserving information.

Books.

Websites.

PDF files.

Archives.

Photographs.

Posts like this one.

But culture is not information alone.

Some things have to be done.

A song that nobody sings is preserved, but it isn’t quite alive.

A ritual nobody performs can remain perfectly documented and still be dead.

A craft described in a book survives intellectually, but something changes when somebody puts tool to material and discovers what the written description left out.

A story can sit safely inside an archive for a thousand years, but it becomes something different when human beings gather and tell it again.

Hands matter.

Perhaps that’s why I keep coming back to the name.

The Hands of Lugh

I don’t know exactly why the founders chose it.

Maybe someone from the organization will eventually tell me and this entire rabbit will acquire another tunnel.

But knowing what we now know, the name no longer looks strange.

A living-history group reconstructing the western Viking diaspora, including material connected with Dublin and the Hiberno-Norse world, carries the name of an Irish mythological figure famous for possessing many skills. That group then helps build a Viking Village at an Icelandic-Canadian festival in a community created by descendants of Icelandic immigrants, themselves heirs to an Icelandic population whose founding ancestry included both Norse and Gaelic people.

That isn’t a historical contradiction.

That’s the North Atlantic world.

Messy.

Connected.

Borrowing.

Trading.

Fighting.

Marrying.

Migrating.

Remembering.

Forgetting.

And reconstructing.

Maybe our modern categories are useful maps, but we should stop mistaking the map for the landscape.

Because somewhere in Manitoba, at an Icelandic festival, a group named for an Irish god is reconstructing Viking Age life using evidence from Iceland, Scandinavia, York, Dublin and the wider western Viking diaspora.

And somehow, after following the rabbit far enough, that stops looking strange altogether.

In fact, it starts looking remarkably appropriate.

Maybe Lugh wasn’t lost in the wrong pantheon.

Maybe we were the ones who put up walls where history never had them.

Sources and Further Reading

What Remains When the Gods Are Gone?

Crowd at Íslendingadagurinn Icelandic Heritage Festival beside waterfront stage and Viking ship

Íslendingadagurinn and the Survival of Cultural Memory

I’ve been chasing this particular rabbit for a while now without really knowing where it was going. We’ve been talking about Pagan history, about memory, about second-generation Pagans, third-generation Pagans, communities disappearing, traditions changing and the uncomfortable question of what actually survives when the people who built something are no longer there to explain it. Then I stumbled across Íslendingadagurinn, the Icelandic Festival of Manitoba, and suddenly there was another version of the question sitting right in front of me.

Íslendingadagurinn means, roughly, “Day of the Icelanders.” It began in Winnipeg in 1890 and eventually moved permanently to Gimli, Manitoba, in 1932. Gimli itself sits inside what was historically known as New Iceland, one of the major Icelandic settlement areas in Canada. Icelandic immigrants began arriving there in significant numbers during the nineteenth century, bringing with them language, stories, customs, identity and, like most Icelanders of that period, Christianity. That last bit matters, because Íslendingadagurinn is not a Pagan festival. It was not created as a Heathen gathering. It is not some uninterrupted survival of pre-Christian Norse religion hiding on the shores of Lake Winnipeg.

And that is precisely why I find it so interesting.

Because more than a century later, look at what remains.

There is a Viking Village. There are demonstrations of Norse crafts and daily life. There are discussions of the Alþingi, settlement, law, trade and the sagas. Icelandic folklore remains visible. Trolls and elves haven’t entirely disappeared from the cultural landscape. Norse imagery remains recognizable. The festival still celebrates the history of the Icelandic people who came to Canada and built a community there, and generations of descendants have continued participating in that celebration long after the original immigrants were gone.

Then there is the Fjallkona, the “Lady of the Mountain,” a symbolic personification of Iceland. Íslendingadagurinn has selected a Fjallkona since 1924. She represents Iceland itself, with Icelanders poetically understood as her children. The symbolism surrounding the figure reaches into older Icelandic imagery involving mountains, ravens, runes and the landscape of Iceland itself. Again, this does not make the ceremony Pagan. Symbols have a strange habit of surviving religions, governments and centuries. Sometimes we remember where they came from. Sometimes we don’t.

And that’s where this rabbit turned around and looked at me.

We’ve been asking what happens when Pagan communities disappear. What survives when the gatherings end, the organizations collapse, the elders die, the newsletters stop being printed and nobody remembers who started what or why something was done a certain way. We tend to think that if the religion survives, the tradition survives. Íslendingadagurinn presents us with almost the opposite experiment.

What happens when the old religion disappears, but the culture keeps remembering?

Apparently, quite a bit survives.

The sagas survive. The ancestral stories survive. Names survive. Food survives. Music survives. Folklore survives. Symbols survive. Historical memory survives. Even pieces of the worldview that produced the old religion can survive, though the people carrying them may no longer understand those things as religious at all.

There is an important distinction here, because I don’t want to commit the same mistake modern Paganism sometimes makes when looking backward. Cultural survival is not the same thing as religious survival. A Viking reenactor is not automatically Heathen. Someone celebrating Icelandic ancestry is not secretly worshipping Odin. A raven on a banner does not turn a cultural festival into a blót. We do ourselves no favours by claiming everything remotely Norse as evidence that the old religion somehow survived intact.

It didn’t.

But perhaps the more interesting question is whether anything ever survives intact.

Maybe religions don’t survive as sealed boxes handed from one generation to the next. Maybe they dissolve into stories, customs, sayings, festivals, family habits, art, language and identity. Some pieces disappear completely. Others get renamed. Some become folklore. Some become children’s stories. Some become cultural symbols. Then, generations later, somebody goes digging through the attic of history and discovers that the supposedly decorative object on the shelf once meant something entirely different.

Modern Paganism has done a great deal of that digging.

Heathenry, Ásatrú, modern Druidry and many other reconstructed or revived traditions exist partly because people deliberately went looking for fragments. Archaeology. Folklore. Sagas. Place names. Medieval manuscripts. Legal codes. Folk customs. Songs. Archaeological remains. The writings of people who were often documenting traditions after conversion had already taken place. We reconstruct because continuity was broken.

But Gimli suggests that broken continuity does not necessarily mean cultural amnesia.

There is another piece of this that interests me even more. Íslendingadagurinn has been carried forward through generations. Children attended with parents. Grandchildren attended with grandparents. Volunteers followed relatives into the organization. People grew up knowing that this thing existed because their family and community kept showing up to do it.

That should sound familiar to anyone who has been following my recent rabbits.

I’ve been wondering where the third-generation Pagans are. I’ve met second-generation Pagans. I’ve met people who grew up at gatherings and festivals and now describe Paganism as “that weird thing my parents did.” Some still attend gatherings because those places are part of their childhood landscape even when the religion itself no longer means quite the same thing to them. Some now have children of their own. Somewhere out there, third-generation Paganism is beginning whether we have noticed it or not.

But what exactly are we handing them?

That may be the lesson hiding inside Íslendingadagurinn.

The Icelandic Canadians of Manitoba did not preserve their identity by writing a manifesto saying Icelandic culture must survive. They preserved it by continuing to do things. They gathered. They told stories. They celebrated. They remembered names. They created institutions. They taught children what the symbols meant. They created something worth returning to, even for descendants whose relationship with Iceland itself became increasingly distant with every generation.

Modern Paganism has spent an enormous amount of energy arguing about belief, legitimacy, labels, lineage and who is Pagan enough to call themselves Pagan. Those conversations sometimes matter. But perhaps we have underestimated the much more mundane machinery of cultural survival.

Who cooks the food?

Who keeps the photographs?

Who tells the story about the year the tent blew away?

Who remembers why the procession goes left instead of right?

Who keeps the old newsletters?

Who teaches the songs?

Who brings their children back?

Who writes down the names of the people in the photograph before everyone who recognizes them is dead?

That is how culture survives.

And perhaps this connects directly to another rabbit we’ve been chasing: maybe Paganism isn’t supposed to survive intact.

That sentence sounds almost heretical when you first say it. Surely preservation is the goal. Surely we want future Pagans to know exactly what we believed, exactly what we practiced and exactly why we did it. But that’s not really how living cultures work. Every generation forgets something. Every generation adds something. Every generation throws away practices that no longer make sense and accidentally preserves things nobody expected to matter.

The Icelandic settlers who arrived in Manitoba could not possibly have known what their descendants would still care about a century and a half later. They couldn’t have predicted Viking reenactors, tourism, heritage parks or modern Canadians rediscovering Icelandic ancestry through genealogy and the internet. They simply created communities and traditions strong enough that later generations had something to inherit.

Maybe that should change the question we ask about Paganism.

Instead of asking, “How do we make sure Paganism survives exactly as we practice it?” perhaps we should ask, “What are we creating that someone will still find worth remembering a hundred years from now?”

That is a much harder question.

Organizations disappear. Festivals end. Websites vanish. Leaders fall out of favour. Communities fracture. The Paganism somebody encounters fifty years from now may barely resemble the Paganism we recognize today.

But perhaps somebody will still light a fire.

Perhaps someone will still tell the stories.

Perhaps a child who spent summers running around a Pagan gathering will bring their own grandchildren back to the same piece of land and say, “This is something our family used to do.”

They may understand it differently.

They may call it something different.

They may even forget why we thought it mattered.

But something will have survived.

Íslendingadagurinn has been doing exactly that for more than a century. Not preserving an ancient Norse religion, but carrying Icelandic cultural memory across generations on Canadian soil.

And maybe the rabbit hiding underneath all of this is surprisingly simple.

Religion can disappear while culture remembers.

Which leaves those of us creating Pagan culture today with a rather uncomfortable question.

What are we doing that is worth remembering?

And if nobody writes any of it down, how will they know?